10 Horror Video Games You Should Avoid Playing in the Dark

Horror video games have a unique way of gripping players and taking them to the edge of their seats, but not all gamers are brave enough to tackle these chilling experiences alone. There’s something inherently terrifying about exploring dark, abandoned places, encountering horrific creatures, and piecing together unsettling narratives—all while knowing that your surroundings are just as quiet and still as the storyline’s ambiance. Whether because of a sudden jump scare or the eerie atmosphere, many horror games can leave players shaken long after the screen goes dark.

With Halloween’s eerie glow now behind us, there’s no better time to dive deep into the world of horror gaming—but be warned! These titles have enough fright factor to keep you from playing solo or, at the very least, definitely not in the dark. Here’s a look at ten horror video games that might just send chills down your spine.

1. Resident Evil Village

The eighth main installment in Capcom’s iconic Resident Evil franchise, Village takes players to a mysterious European village filled with grotesque creatures. From haunting werewolf-like enemies to the chilling presence of Lady Dimitrescu, this game utilizes shocking visuals and incredible sound design to create an atmosphere of dread. Playing through its halls at night? Forget it.

2. Amnesia: The Dark Descent

Widely regarded as one of the scariest games ever made, Amnesia thrusts players into a haunting world where darkness is your enemy. The reliance on psychological horror and a strong narrative makes wandering through its dimly lit corridors a harrowing experience. The ominous sounds and unsettling visuals are just too much for a dark room!

3. Outlast

Outlast places you in an abandoned psychiatric hospital, where you play as a journalist investigating the horrific incidents within its walls. The game relies heavily on stealth and evasion, as you have no weapons to defend yourself against the horrifying creatures lurking in the shadows. The fear of the unknown—and not being able to fight back—makes this title a must-avoid for dark playing sessions.

4. Silent Hill 2

Often hailed as one of the best horror games of all time, Silent Hill 2 immerses players in a psychologically disturbing narrative. The fog-laden town and grotesque monsters are coupled with a haunting soundtrack that persists long after you’ve put the game down. Playing this classic on a dark night is an experience best shared.

5. PT (Playable Teaser)

Even though PT was a demo intended for a cancelled Silent Hill project, it remains one of the most frightening experiences in gaming history. The game’s simple premise—a looped hallway filled with increasingly bizarre and terrifying occurrences—will leave even the bravest players quaking in fear. The tension builds steadily, making it best to keep the lights on if you dare to try it.

6. Dead Space

Step into the shoes of Isaac Clarke as he battles grotesque Necromorphs aboard a derelict spaceship. The combination of dark corridors, dismemberment mechanics, and an unsettling atmosphere means that Dead Space serves up its scares with a side of sheer dread. The game’s intensity demands a bright room—or a buddy to keep an eye on those shadows!

7. Soma

From the creators of Amnesia, Soma offers a more philosophical take on horror, exploring themes of consciousness and identity in an underwater facility. But don’t let its existential musings fool you—the submerged horrors lurking in the depths can be mind-bendingly terrifying. Prepare yourself for unsettling jump scares and deeply eerie environments.

8. The Evil Within

Developed by Shinji Mikami—the mastermind behind the Resident Evil series—The Evil Within disturbs players with grotesque imagery and psychological elements. The game’s oppressive atmosphere and relentless enemies offer a harrowing experience that’s amplified in the dark. Trust us; you will jump!

9. Until Dawn

In this interactive horror experience, players make choices that can lead to different outcomes for a group of friends who are being hunted by a mysterious killer. The game is filled with jump scares, moral dilemmas, and enough tension to make you scream. Playing this thriller with the lights off may result in panicked decisions!

10. Layers of Fear

Focusing on psychological horror and the exploration of a painter’s sanity, Layers of Fear manipulates perception and reality in astonishing ways. The ever-changing environment and surreal visuals create a thick tension, guaranteeing that players will never know what’s coming next. The chilling story coupled with its eerie graphics means it’s best enjoyed under the warmth of a lamp.