Why “Wicked” Deserves the Best Picture Oscar

As the curtain rises on Jon M. Chu’s much-anticipated adaptation of “Wicked,” the striking visuals and immersive production set a vibrant tone that pays homage to the golden age of musicals. A staggering 9 million real tulips planted by a dedicated farmer in Norfolk serve as the backdrop for this ambitious retelling of a classic story. It’s a bold statement against the modern convenience of CGI, with the director and production designer Nathan Crowley aiming for a level of authenticity that reflects the essence of the original “Oz.” This commitment to opulence and palpable magic leads us to a compelling argument: why “Wicked” should be in contention for the Best Picture Oscar.

Grounded in Realism

While CGI has its place in contemporary cinema, it often lacks the emotional depth that comes from tangible artistry. The lush flora of “Wicked” isn’t just a visual feast; it evokes the optimism that Technicolor once brought to cinema nearly a century ago. Chu’s vision doesn’t merely rely on visual splendor; it captures the heart and spirit of storytelling in a way that resonates deeply with audiences, reminding us of the magic of cinema that is often overshadowed by technology.

Authentic Performances

One of the most defining choices in “Wicked” is the decision by stars Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo to perform all their songs live. While lip-syncing has become ubiquitous in the film industry, it often sacrifices the raw emotional connection between performers and their audience. Grande and Erivo, both powerhouse vocalists, evoke a palpable energy and authenticity that breathes life into their characters. Their performances reflect not only technical skill but also an intimate understanding of the songs’ emotional weight. Audiences can feel the muscles in a singer’s throat as they convey powerful stories of friendship, love, and resilience. This authenticity makes their chemistry resonate on screen, and it’s transcendent, drawing viewers in with the intimacy of a genuine connection.

A Unique Dynamic

The chemistry between Grande and Erivo goes beyond mere performance; it’s akin to a chemical reaction, sparking curiosity and admiration from fans everywhere. The palpable bond forged between the two actresses has sparked widespread speculation on social media, with fans even mistaking their camaraderie for romance. Their connection brings depth to the narrative, particularly in songs like “What is This Feeling?”—a catchy, whimsical number that explores the complexities of their intertwined fates. Their friendship, complete with matching tattoos and heartfelt emotional exchanges, adds a layer of sincerity that elevates the storytelling.

The Challenge of Adaption

Adapting a beloved stage musical is no easy feat, especially one that began as a layered narrative filled with intense themes and intricate character development. “Wicked” is often viewed as a slow burn, with melodies that take time to grow on you, much like an avant-garde album that requires multiple listens to appreciate fully. The decision to split the film into two parts, stretching the story into a grand runtime, defies modern cinematic trends focused on brevity and immediate gratification. Yet, this approach is a show of confidence—a belief that audiences will embrace its complexities if given time. The film effectively mirrors the musical’s intricate themes while adding a cinematic grandeur that only enhances the experience.

Fresh Twists and Political Resonance

One of the more curious aspects of the original “Wicked” musical is its subplot concerning talking animals and a monkey army. The film’s reinterpretation of this subplot introduces political relevance and emotional depth that is absent in the stage version. By positioning Dr. Dillamond, the talking goat, as a symbol for marginalized voices, the film is able to tackle themes of totalitarianism and societal conformity more effectively. The complex relationship between Glinda and Elphaba becomes even more poignant when viewed through this lens, emphasizing the choices that individuals must make when faced with oppression. This consideration of sociopolitical contexts reinforces the film’s relevance, especially within today’s gnarled cultural landscape.

Conclusion: A Musical Masterpiece Deserving of Recognition

In a year chock-full of remarkable films, “Wicked” stands out not just for its production value, but for its passionate execution and profound themes. The commitment to authenticity, the brilliance of live performances, and the political added weight are a testament to why it deserves to be in contention for Best Picture at the Oscars.

As we move into 2024, the essence of “Wicked” captures the hopeful spirit that cinema once embodied. It invites audiences to confront their beliefs and feel deeply—qualities essential for any great film. By betting on genuine creativity, heartfelt performances, and innovative storytelling, “Wicked” reminds us of the magic that cinema can offer when it dares to be bold.